I'm going to take a break from my usual bellyaching and pass along something substantial I learned. I was trying to learn how long the
O's could keep Rich Hill in rehab assignments. I wound up with a long trip through
MLB's official rules and Collective Bargaining Agreement. Here is what I learned.
Going on the Disabled List isn't as automatic as I thought. Teams can't just put players on the
DL. They actually submit an application package to the Commissioner's office, the player, and the union. See
CBA, page 47. Also, the
official rules, 3.17, although that doesn't apply to Hill. It is more about players on the
DL but still physically present with the major league club.
Implicit in the wording is that the Commissioner, player, or union could reject the application. The player also has the right to seek a second medical opinion.
Does it seem unlikely that the team and player wouldn't agree? Apparently it happens fairly often at the minor league level. Chris
Coste, the Phil's backup catcher, wrote about it in his book,
The 33-Year-Old Rookie. While in the minors with another organization,
Coste lost his AAA job when the organization added a veteran catcher. Rather than releasing him, the team asked him to go on the
DL with a phantom injury.
Coste refused, opting to become a free agent. If the player is compliant though, there doesn't seem to be much preventing a team from keeping a player on the
DL for quite a while.
So lets say Hill comes off the
DL shortly. Word is the
O's want start him with a minor league rehab assignment. How long can that last? Quite a while.
Referring to the
CBA again (pg. 50), players with more than five years of major league service can refuse a rehab assignment. Jeff Weaver did that a couple years ago when he was a Mariner. The M's were forced to build his arm strength from the bullpen. Hill, who has less than five years service, can be forced to accept a 20 day rehab assignment. However, if he gives written consent, that assignment can be longer.
The short answer to my initial question is that if Hill is willing to stay on the
DL and/or accept a long rehab assignment, there is no limit on how long it might take him to get to Baltimore. I suppose sooner or later, Hill will get tired of pitching
BP to 19-year-
olds. I suppose sooner or later, the
O's will get tired of paying Hill for nothing while Simon and Eaton struggle. For now, neither side seems to be in a hurry. Hill is going to hang around minor league camp trying to build arm strength and control. We are going to watch Adam Eaton face the Red
Sox.